Cities

Data Sources

NYS Comptroller (OSC) — City Financials

The NYS Office of the State Comptroller collects Annual Financial Reports (AFRs) from local governments across New York State. BenchmarkUSA imports this data for 61 of 62 cities. New York City has its own Comptroller and does not file with OSC — NYC data comes from the NYC Comptroller's ACFR (see below).

By November 7, 2026, 57 of the 61 cities had filed for fiscal year 2024 and 51 for 2025. Four cities have not filed for 2024; the late and non-filing cities page lists them. The data includes revenue, expenditure, and balance sheet amounts at the fund and account-code level.

NYC Comptroller ACFR — NYC Financials

New York City operates under its own Comptroller and is not part of the OSC reporting system. NYC financial data comes from the Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (ACFR) published by the NYC Comptroller's office. We import the Ten Year Trend statistical tables (FY 2016-2026), which provide expenditures by functional category and agency, revenue by source, and fund balance classifications.

Key differences from OSC data: NYC's fiscal year runs July 1 - June 30 (most other NY cities use the calendar year). NYC's General Fund balance is entirely Restricted and Committed (including a ~$2B Revenue Stabilization Fund) — there is no Unassigned General Fund balance. All ACFR values are reported "in thousands" and are multiplied by 1,000 during import.

US Census Bureau (ACS)

Population, income, poverty, and housing data comes from the American Community Survey (5-year estimates) via the Census Bureau API. We hold the five-year estimates ending in 2010 through those ending in 2024, all fifteen for every New York city. Some places have fewer years, and a few have no estimates of their own, such as Mountain House, California, a city since 2024.

ACS 5-year estimates are based on survey samples and carry margins of error. For small cities, these margins can be significant. We use point estimates throughout the application.

How City Metrics Are Calculated

The three headline metrics used in city rankings and entity dashboards are derived from OSC and Census data:

Fund Balance %
Available Fund Balance divided by Total Expenditures, as a percentage. Available Fund Balance is the general fund's committed, assigned and unassigned balances (OSC accounts A913, A914, A915 and A917; for New York City, its committed general-fund balance). Credit analysts read these together as a city's usable reserves: unassigned alone can read near zero when a city moves money into a committed reserve. These accounts exist from fiscal year 2011 (GASB Statement No. 54); we do not substitute older accounts for earlier years. The county comparison chart uses Unassigned Fund Balance alone: A917 from 2011, and A910 + A911 before.
Debt Service %
Total Debt Service (all accounts in the Debt Service category) divided by Total Expenditures, expressed as a percentage. A lower percentage typically indicates less debt burden.
Operating Ratio
Total Revenue divided by Total Expenditures, expressed as a percentage. Values above 100% indicate a surplus (revenues exceed expenditures); below 100% indicates a deficit. Both revenue and expenditure totals exclude interfund transfers and Trust & Custodial fund pass-throughs.
Per-Capita Spending
Total Expenditures divided by population (from Census ACS data). Provides a normalized comparison of spending across cities of different sizes.

All-Fund Approach

Expenditure and revenue totals include all fund types (General, Highway, Water, Sewer, Enterprise, etc.) with three exclusions:

  • Trust & Custodial Fund (T-fund) — Cities in Westchester and Nassau counties act as tax collectors for county and school district taxes. These pass-through amounts are reported in the T-fund and can inflate apparent expenditures by 40-50%. We exclude the entire T-fund to remove these pass-throughs.
  • Interfund Transfers — When cities move money between funds, OSC reports these as expenditures ("Other Uses") and revenues ("Other Sources") at the fund level. Including both would double-count money moving between a city's own accounts. Cities' own ACFRs eliminate these in government-wide statements per GASB standards. We do the same.
  • Proceeds of Debt — When a city issues bonds or notes, the proceeds appear on the revenue side as "Proceeds of Debt." This is borrowing, not earned revenue — it creates a matching liability. GASB classifies debt proceeds separately from operating revenue. OSC's own "Total Revenues" summary columns exclude this category. We follow the same treatment.

These exclusions apply consistently across all entity types (cities, counties, school districts, and towns/villages). Interfund transfers and debt proceeds are filtered out at import, so they never enter the database. Trust and custodial fund rows are stored and left out of every figure we add up: totals, rankings, per-capita figures, category charts, debt service and our MCP server's figures. One rule in our code says which rows add up, and every sum reads it (until November 8, 2026, category charts and debt service read their own; see Corrections).

Fund Structure Variation

Cities organize their finances differently. Some run water and sewer operations through the General Fund (A), while others use dedicated Enterprise (E), Water (F), and Sewer (G) funds. Debt service may appear in any fund. The all-fund approach handles this correctly by including all legitimate spending regardless of fund structure.

City Data Limitations

  • Late and non-filing cities — Not all cities file their Annual Financial Reports on time. Four cities have not filed for 2024, the most significant case being Mount Vernon, whose last filing is for 2020 and which lost its credit rating due to years of non-filing. View filing compliance details.
  • GASB 54 and fund balance classification — The "Unassigned Fund Balance" metric (account code A917) only exists from 2011 onward, when GASB Statement No. 54 reclassified fund balances from Reserved/Unreserved into Nonspendable, Restricted, Committed, Assigned, and Unassigned categories. Some cities also reclassify fund balance between categories year to year. For example, Buffalo reported no Unassigned Fund Balance for 2018-2020, instead categorizing its entire General Fund balance as Assigned or Restricted during those years.
  • Early year coverage — Data coverage is sparser in the earliest years (1995-2000) as fewer cities had filed electronically.
  • Census margins of error — ACS 5-year estimates are survey-based and carry margins of error, particularly for smaller cities.

Counties

Data Sources

County financial data comes from the same NYS Comptroller (OSC) Annual Financial Reports used for cities. Data covers all 57 New York counties (excluding the five NYC boroughs, which are not separate counties in the OSC system) from 1995 to the most recently available fiscal year.

California county figures come from the State Controller's Office. Its fiscal year 2025 county data lists some amounts more than once: debt principal under two line names with one amount, and in some enterprise funds one interest amount on three lines. We count each repeated amount once. Two counties' audited reports show their debt principal once; we have asked the Controller's office to confirm the rest.

County Partisan Comparison

The County Comparison page plots three fiscal health metrics against the partisan composition of each county's legislature (from the November 2025 elections):

  • Operating Ratio — Revenue / Expenditures. Above 100% = surplus.
  • Fund Balance % — Unassigned fund balance / Expenditures. Uses A917 (GASB 54, FY 2011+) or A910+A911 (pre-GASB 54) for historical consistency.
  • Debt Service % — Debt service payments / Expenditures.

The conservative share of each county council is calculated as (Republican + Conservative not also Republican) / total council members. Partisan data is from the November 2025 election results and does not change when viewing different fiscal years — only the financial metrics change.

Towns & Villages

Data Sources

NYS Comptroller (OSC) — Town & Village Financials

Town and village financial data comes from the NYS Comptroller's Annual Financial Reports, which the Comptroller publishes in two forms. We use each for a different job.

  • Account-level files (one row per account code, fiscal year 1995 to present) — Revenue and spending totals are added up from these, across every fund except Trust & Custodial funds, which hold money a town or village keeps on behalf of others, such as taxes it collects for other governments. This is the same all-fund approach used for cities. A year shows one filed report: when a village changes its fiscal year and files two reports under one year, the year shows its 12-month report and the page's Data Notes give the other report's dates and totals. A year filed as one report of another length, such as fourteen months, is shown as filed, with a note.
  • Summary workbooks (the Comptroller's "Level 2" files: one row per government, about 180 columns, fiscal years 1997 to 2025) — These supply debt outstanding, full value of taxable property, land area and the Comptroller's population figure. Their revenue and spending columns are a second copy of the same dollars. We keep them as a check on the account-level totals and never add them to those totals.

Per-resident figures divide by the Census Bureau's population estimate for the newest year at or before the fiscal year. The Comptroller's population figure, which repeats the 2010 or 2020 census count from year to year, is used only for a place with no Census estimate at or before that year. A town's residents outside its villages are the town's figure less each village's own, found the same way; if any of its villages has no figure, or its villages' figures add up to more than the town's, that number is not shown. A place whose population figure is zero has no per-resident figure.

Coterminous Town-Villages

Several New York towns have village boundaries identical to the town boundary. In these "coterminous" pairs, the village government handles all municipal services and financial reporting while the town exists as a separate legal entity with no independent budget. Towns of East Rochester, Mount Kisco, and Scarsdale report zero financial data for FY 1997–2008 because their respective villages reported all finances. Starting in FY 2009, these towns began filing separate reports with OSC.

This structure exists because villages in New York have broader authority than towns for urban-level services (police, fire, water, sewer, zoning). When a village fills its entire town, the village government effectively runs everything. Formal merger requires state legislative action, so most coterminous pairs remain separate legal entities even when one government is vestigial.

Dissolved Villages

31 New York villages in our data have dissolved, from 1993 to 2023; 27 of them since the 2009 "Citizen Empowerment Act", which streamlined the dissolution process and offered a property tax credit incentive. Dissolved villages are marked with a "Dissolved" badge and retain their historical financial data through the year of dissolution. They are excluded from rankings and active comparisons.

Source: NYS Department of State — Village Dissolution

School Districts

Data Sources

NYS Comptroller (OSC) — School District Financials

The NYS Office of the State Comptroller publishes annual financial data for all 689 school districts in New York State. BenchmarkUSA imports this data from fiscal year 2015.

Unlike city data (which uses a long format with one row per account code), school district data is published in a wide format — one row per district per year with approximately 180 columns representing pre-aggregated category totals covering revenue by source (property taxes, state aid, federal aid), expenditures by function (instruction, administration, transportation, debt service), balance sheet items, enrollment, and property values.

NYS Education Department (NYSED) — Outcomes Data

The New York State Education Department publishes assessment results, graduation rates, and enrollment demographics for all school districts. We have downloaded graduation rates (2012–2025), Grades 3–8 assessment results (2014–2021), and enrollment demographics (2018–2025). Import of this outcomes data is planned for a future release.

Note: 2019–20 state assessments were cancelled due to COVID-19 school closures, so that year has no assessment data.

District Types

New York has five legal classifications for school districts, each with distinct governance and fiscal structures:

  • Central (546 districts) — The most common type. Consolidated districts serving multiple municipalities, typically in rural and suburban areas. This category includes "Independent Superintendent" and "Central High" variants, which share the same legal structure.
  • Union Free (72 districts) — Independent districts formed by vote of multiple school districts, typically in suburban areas.
  • City — Big Five (4 in OSC data) — Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse, and Yonkers. These districts are fiscally dependent on their parent cities — their budgets require city approval. NYC is also a Big Five district but operates under its own Comptroller and is not in OSC data.
  • City — Small City (57 districts) — Districts coterminous with smaller New York cities (population under 125,000). While they have some fiscal relationship with their city, they have greater budgetary independence than the Big Five.
  • Common (10 districts) — The oldest form of school district in New York, governed by trustees rather than a board of education. In fiscal year 2025, those reporting enrollment had from 13 to 224 students. Despite the name, they are not one-room schoolhouses — they operate modern facilities but retain the historic "common school" designation.

How School District Metrics Are Calculated

The headline metrics used in school district comparisons are:

Per-Pupil Spending
Total Expenditures divided by Enrollment. The primary measure for comparing spending across districts of different sizes.
Per-Pupil Instruction
Instruction expenditures divided by Enrollment. Isolates spending that directly supports classroom teaching.
Per-Pupil Administration
Administration expenditures divided by Enrollment. Measures administrative spending relative to student body size.
Administrative Overhead %
Administration expenditures divided by Total Expenditures. Measures how much of the budget goes to administration versus instruction and other services.
State Aid Dependency %
Total State Aid divided by Total Revenue. Measures fiscal independence — higher values indicate greater reliance on state funding and more vulnerability to state budget cuts.

Big Five: Separate Data, No Double-Counting

The Big Five school districts (Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse, Yonkers) are fiscally dependent on their parent cities, which raises a natural question about whether importing both city and school district data leads to double-counting. It does not — OSC assigns entirely separate municipal codes and financial reports to cities and their school districts. We verified this by comparing FY 2024 expenditures:

  • Buffalo — city operations: $790M, school district: $1.28B
  • Rochester — city operations: $810M, school district: $1.08B
  • Syracuse — city operations: $436M, school district: $624M
  • Yonkers — city operations: $757M, school district: $830M

City figures leave out interfund transfers and the trust and custodial fund. In all four cases, school district spending exceeds municipal operations spending. We link Big Five districts to their parent city entity to reflect the fiscal dependency relationship.

Exclusions

  • BOCES — Boards of Cooperative Educational Services are regional shared-service providers. They don't serve students directly and have no enrollment figures for per-pupil calculations. Districts that use BOCES services report those costs as expenditures in their own filings.
  • Charter schools — Not included in OSC's school district bulk data. NYSED tracks charter schools separately under different financial reporting requirements.
  • NYC Department of Education — Not in OSC data. NYC operates under its own Comptroller. NYC city-level financial data is imported from the ACFR, but school district-level breakdowns are not yet available.

School District Data Limitations

  • Pre-2015 data not loaded — We hold school district data from fiscal year 2015; city data goes back to 1995.
  • District mergers — A small number of districts have consolidated over time (e.g., Berkshire, Elizabethtown-Lewis, Westport). We do not currently track historical lineage — each year's filing stands alone under the district name that filed it. We hope to cover these mergers soon, not because they involve large numbers of students, but because they may serve as useful case studies for other districts considering consolidation — particularly around whether economies of scale produce cost savings without detrimental impact to outcomes.
  • Outlier districts — A few districts have unusual structures that produce extreme per-pupil figures. For example, Kiryas Joel Village Union Free School District reports ~$385,000 per pupil because it operates exclusively as a special education provider for a community where most children attend private religious schools. Its enrollment of 176 students in fiscal year 2024 counts only the public special education program, while expenditures cover services for the broader community.
  • Enrollment timing — OSC enrollment figures are point-in-time snapshots that may differ slightly from NYSED's audited enrollment counts.
  • NYSED outcomes not yet imported — We have downloaded graduation rates, assessment results, and demographics from NYSED but have not yet integrated them into the application. This is planned for a future release and will enable spending-vs-outcomes analysis.

Other States

California

City and county financial data comes from the California State Controller's Office, which collects a Financial Transactions Report from every city and county and publishes it as open data. We hold cities and counties for fiscal years 2003 to 2025. California's fiscal year runs July 1 to June 30; "2024" means the year ending June 30, 2024. San Francisco, a consolidated city and county, files as a city. Transfers and other financing sources are left out of revenue, as they are for New York. Each time we import the Controller's published data into our database, we then compare our totals with the Controller's own published totals, to the dollar, for every year the Controller has published them: through 2024 as of November 7, 2026, so 2025 is not yet checked. School districts and special districts are not included: they report to other agencies or in separate datasets.

Florida

City and county financial data comes from the Florida Department of Financial Services, which receives an Annual Financial Report from every local government. We hold fiscal years 2013 to 2025. Most Florida local governments end their fiscal year on September 30; "2025" means the year ending September 30, 2025. The Department lists every municipality as a city; we show each as a city, town or village following the Census Bureau. Where the Department publishes an account both as one figure and broken down by fund, we store the breakdown, and every import reports any account whose figure differs from its breakdown's sum by a dollar or more. Every import also compares each government's revenue and spending for the year with the Department's own totals for it (its report of total revenues, expenditures and debt) and names any government whose figures differ from them by a dollar or more. The Department's file prints some figures twice (from fiscal year 2021 on, every impact fee); we count a figure once however many times it is printed, and an import stops if two printings of one figure disagree (until November 10, 2026, each printing was added; see Corrections). A Florida government's figures count the funds it runs for itself. The Department's file reports every account by fund group, twelve in all. We count eight (general, special revenue, debt service, capital projects, permanent, enterprise, internal service and component units) and leave out the four that hold money for others: custodial funds, such as the taxes a county collects for its school district and cities, and pension, investment and private-purpose trust funds. The Department's own totals for fiscal year 2024 leave out the same four. The rule covers revenue, spending and balance-sheet figures in every year we hold, and an import stops if a figure in the file is filed under a fund group outside the twelve (until November 10, 2026, every fund was added; see Corrections). Under the heading "Other Sources" the Department files several kinds of money. We count the interest and grants that a government's enterprise and internal service funds receive, and chart them under the Department's heading for them, "Proprietary Non-Operating Sources". We leave out the rest: transfers between a government's own funds and from a county's elected officers, contributions from its enterprise operations, debt, lease and refunding proceeds, sales of capital assets and payments for their loss, capital contributions, other non-operating sources, and extraordinary and special items (until November 14, 2026, the interest and grants were left out too; see Corrections). An import also stops if a figure of a government it reads is filed under an account that is not on our list of the Department's accounts (until November 11, 2026, such a figure was left out without notice; see Corrections). It reads each government we hold that is in the Department's main file for the year; from fiscal year 2021 on, six accounts come from a second request, and a government found only there is reported and none of its figures is read. School districts and special districts are not included.

North Carolina

City, town, village and county financial data comes from the Annual Financial Information Report collected by the North Carolina Department of State Treasurer. We hold fiscal years 2012 to 2025; the fiscal year ends June 30. Census-designated places are unincorporated and file no report, so they carry no figures of their own; a community whose town has dissolved keeps the years that town filed. The Treasurer publishes spending two ways, by function and by type of expense. We add up the by-function figures and keep the other breakdown for reference, so no dollar is counted twice. Every import ends with an error if our lines and the Treasurer's own totals differ by more than $1. School districts and special districts are not included.

Comparability Notes

Some places' figures cannot be compared one for one with their peers'. Each such place carries a comparability note, printed on its own page. Most notes follow one of the rules below, so the rule is stated here once.

426 New York places carry a comparability note: 2 cities, 7 school districts, 387 towns, and 30 villages.

Towns that contain villages

A New York town with villages inside it shows two per-resident spending figures. Town-Wide Per Capita Spending is what the town spends from the funds that serve the whole town, its town-wide general and highway funds (the Comptroller's A and DA funds), divided by all of the town's residents, village residents included. Part-Town Per Capita Spending is what it spends from the funds that serve only the area outside its villages (the B and DB funds), divided by the residents outside the villages. Neither counts money moved from one fund to another. Residents are counted as described under Towns & Villages above. For example, the Town of Amherst in Erie County contains the Village of Williamsville, so its page shows both figures.

Villages in more than one town

Some villages lie in two or more towns, and a few also cross a county line, so their residents in different counties pay different county taxes. The Comptroller reports each such village under one of its towns. Because we do not know how many of a village's residents live in each town, the 53 towns such a village touches show no Part-Town Per Capita Spending. For example, the Village of North Syracuse lies in the Towns of Clay and Cicero in Onondaga County; the Comptroller reports it under Clay, and neither town shows a Part-Town figure.

Other towns

A few towns share their whole boundary with a village (see Coterminous Town-Villages above; for example, Scarsdale), and a few have years with no financial filing, which their notes name (for example, the Town of Baldwin in Chemung County, which has reported no financial data since FY 2020).

Cities and school districts

These notes are each one of a kind, so they are printed here in full.

  • Fire Island Union Free School District —

    Fire Island typically enrolls fewer than 50 students across a barrier island community. Per-pupil spending reflects fixed costs, geographic isolation, and seasonal population shifts.

  • Greenburgh Eleven Union Free School District —

    Greenburgh Eleven serves youth in residential treatment facilities, not a geographic catchment area. High per-pupil spending reflects specialized population costs.

  • Hawthorne-Cedar Knolls Union Free School District —

    Hawthorne-Cedar Knolls serves youth in residential treatment facilities (formerly the Jewish Board of Family and Children's Services campus). High per-pupil spending reflects specialized population costs, not geographic district operations.

  • Kiryas Joel Village Union Free School District —

    Kiryas Joel serves an ultra-Orthodox Hasidic community (Village of Palm Tree/KJ). Very high special education placement rates and poverty rates reflect community structure, not conventional fiscal distress. Created by state legislation (1989). Per-pupil comparisons with conventional districts are misleading.

  • New Suffolk Common School District —

    New Suffolk typically enrolls fewer than 15 students. Per-pupil spending figures reflect fixed operational costs spread across minimal enrollment.

  • New York City —

    Consolidated city-county-school district. NYC's General Fund includes K-12 education (DOE, ~$34B), courts, district attorneys, and public welfare — functions handled at the county or school district level in other cities. This makes per-capita spending roughly 2-3x higher than otherwise comparable cities. Fund Balance % reflects only the Committed General Fund (Revenue Stabilization Fund, ~$2B); NYC's larger reserves are classified as Restricted and are not included.

  • Plattsburgh —

    Operates a municipal electric utility (Enterprise Fund). Utility revenues and expenditures inflate total spending relative to cities without municipal utilities.

  • Sagaponack Common School District —

    Sagaponack typically enrolls fewer than 15 students. Per-pupil spending figures (often exceeding $100K) reflect fixed operational costs spread across minimal enrollment, not instructional spending levels.

  • Wainscott Common School District —

    Wainscott typically enrolls fewer than 30 students. Per-pupil spending figures reflect fixed operational costs spread across minimal enrollment.

Cities with a comparability note are left out of the state page's per-capita spending ranking. They stay in the fund balance and debt service rankings, where the structural differences matter less.

Fiscal Stress Monitoring System (FSMS)

The OSC's Fiscal Stress Monitoring System evaluates the fiscal health of local governments across New York State using a composite scoring system. FSMS covers New York's cities, counties, towns, villages, and school districts, but not New York City (which has its own Comptroller and is not in the OSC system).

How FSMS Scoring Works

Each entity receives two scores on a 0-100 scale:

  • Fiscal Stress Score — Based on financial indicators including fund balance adequacy, cash position, operating deficits, and short-term borrowing.
  • Socio-Demographic Stress Score — Based on external factors including poverty rates, population change, property value trends, and local economic conditions. (OSC calls this "Environmental Stress" — we use "Socio-Demographic" to avoid confusion with ecological/environmental metrics.)

Based on these scores, entities receive a designation: "Significant Fiscal Stress," "Moderate Fiscal Stress," "Susceptible to Fiscal Stress," or "No Designation." The Stress Analysis page visualizes these scores interactively.

Scoring Methodology Changes

The scoring methodology changed in 2017. Pre-2017 scores used a 29-point weighted system for municipalities or a 21-point system for school districts, with individual indicator scores reported as fractions (0.0-1.0). From 2017 onward, scores use a direct 100-point scale. We normalize pre-2017 scores to the 100-point scale for trend consistency.

FSMS Data Coverage

  • Cities, counties, towns, and villages: 2012-2025
  • School districts: 2013-2025

Data is imported from the OSC's published Excel workbooks. Entities that did not file their Annual Financial Report are marked "Not filed" and excluded from scoring for that year.

FSMS Exemptions

  • NYC — Has its own Comptroller, not in the OSC system.
  • Big Five school districts (Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse, Yonkers) — Fiscally dependent on parent cities; their finances are reflected in the parent city's FSMS score.
  • Union Free special-act school districts — Special-purpose districts serving institutions, exempt from standard FSMS scoring.

Property Tax Burden

Property-tax comparisons answer two related but different questions: what a household should expect to pay at a specific address, and how much a government collects from the property-tax base serving that address. We keep those measures separate.

Resident-Facing Estimates

The preferred resident-facing presentation is an estimated annual residential bill for the user's scenario, broken out by levy authority. We also show an effective tax rate where the required inputs exist: estimated net bill divided by the property's market value. This is more comparable across jurisdictions than a raw statutory rate because assessment ratios, phase-ins, exemptions, tax classes, credits, caps, and special districts vary by state and locality.

Every estimate should disclose its assumptions: market value, assessed value, taxable value, class, credits or caps applied, and whether parcel-specific districts or fees are included. We also show source freshness for each component, such as current, stale latest-available, non-ACFR current actual, missing, or parcel-required.

When we label a row modeled pre-credit, the number is not a parcel-exact bill and should not be read as a net household liability. For the Metro-DC Maryland pilot, we combine the official State of Maryland, county, and municipal rates published by SDAT for July 1, 2025 tax bills, then multiply that combined rate by SDAT's county residential weighted assessment ratio. Homestead caps, exemptions, credits, taxable-value phase-ins, and parcel-specific districts are disclosed but not applied until we have parcel or scenario inputs that support them. DC and Northern Virginia modeled rows are shown on an assessed-value basis: DC uses the OTR residential class rate, and NOVA rows combine the applicable county, independent-city, and incorporated-town rates where the official source exposes them. Special districts, service charges, relief programs, credits, exemptions, and parcel-specific assessment facts remain excluded unless separately modeled.

Aggregate Civic Burden

Aggregate civic burden uses audited or official property-tax revenue and levy rows, divided by population or household denominators, to describe what a government collects from the tax base. This is useful fiscal context, but it does not predict what a particular homeowner will owe. Aggregate revenue can include commercial, industrial, rental, personal-property, utility, penalty, and interest amounts depending on the source's taxonomy.

When aggregate rows are shown, we identify the levy authority, reporting or billing authority, denominator geography, fiscal year, and selected source row. We do not collapse state, county, municipal, school, or special-district rows into one authority unless the source explicitly defines that total.

Source Priority

  1. Parcel exact — actual parcel assessment, tax bill, or official tax record, including exemptions and special districts.
  2. Modeled effective rate — official current rates plus official assessment, taxable-value, credit, and cap rules for a representative scenario.
  3. Assessment-rate estimate — official rates and assessment semantics when the full credit or cap model is not available.
  4. Aggregate civic burden — audited or official property-tax revenue or levy rows by authority and denominator geography.
  5. Typical reported burden — ACS or similar household survey metrics, clearly labeled as reported historical context rather than the user's bill.

Source Notes

Raw rates are source facts, not comparable burden measures by themselves. For example, Maryland property-tax bills are based on assessment multiplied by state, county, and municipal rates, with reassessment phase-in and credits such as the Homestead credit affecting the amount billed. Other states use different assessment ratios, caps, and local taxing structures.

Our cross-jurisdiction property-tax presentation follows the same practical lesson used in property-tax comparison research: compare net bills and effective rates where possible, and keep valuation assumptions visible because assessment accuracy affects the distribution of tax burdens.

Data Quality Controls

Cross-Checking Against Source Totals

Where a source publishes its own totals, we check that the lines we store add up to them. For New York school districts, New York City and North Carolina, every import ends with an error if a government's revenue or spending for a year differs from the source's total by more than $1, and that error also undoes the whole import, so none of its figures is stored. New York City's report also prints its latest year's revenue and spending a second time, in whole dollars, in the General Fund's own schedules; after every import we compare each New York City figure we store for that year with its line there, rounded to the thousand dollars our figures are given in, and report by name any figure more than $1,000 off and any we cannot find there; the import goes on. Both come from the Comptroller, so this catches a figure our import misread, but not an error the Comptroller makes in both. North Carolina's report also lists each government's revenue in detail below the summary we show; every import adds up that detail, leaves out money moved in from the government's own other funds and money paid into escrow to retire refunded bonds, compares the result with the Treasurer's revenue total, and reports by name any difference of $1 or more; the import goes on. For Florida, every import compares each account's published figure with the sum of its breakdown by fund and reports any difference of $1 or more, and compares each government's revenue and spending with the Department's own totals, reporting by name any difference of $1 or more. California's totals are compared with the Controller's own published totals, to the dollar, by a check we run by hand after each import of the Controller's data; it is not yet built into the import itself. New York's town and village account-level files publish no totals. After every import of either file, we compare each town's and village's revenue and spending with the Comptroller's second rendering of the same filings, the Level Two summary workbooks, and report by name any difference larger than rounding (50 cents per nonzero summary line) and the trust funds that some years' summaries count; the import goes on. Both files come from the Comptroller, so the comparison catches a line our import dropped, doubled or misread, and a figure that differs between the two files, but not an error the Comptroller makes in both (see Corrections for the 2026 rebuild).

City and county data uses a long format (one row per account code) without embedded totals, so cross-checking requires comparing our aggregated values against OSC's published summary reports.

Non-Operating Category Filtering

All four OSC importers (cities, counties, school districts, towns/villages) filter out non-operating categories at import time. This prevents interfund transfers ("Other Sources" / "Other Uses") and debt proceeds from inflating revenue and expenditure totals. The specific categories excluded vary slightly by entity type to match OSC's naming conventions, but the principle is the same: only operating revenue and expenditure enters the database.

Metric Classification Validation

Each imported metric is classified as revenue, expenditure, or balance sheet based on its position in the source data. For wide-format files (school districts, towns, villages), column position determines the section. For long-format files (cities, counties), the ACCOUNT_CODE_SECTION or FINANCIAL_STATEMENT field in each row determines the classification. We validate these classifications against known patterns and fix any mismatches discovered during cross-checking.

How We Check Our Work

  • Against the source's own totals — Where a source publishes a total, we add up the lines we store for each government and year and compare the two. This is the check that found the error listed under Corrections below.
  • Tests before code — A change to how a number is read or calculated starts with a test that fails until the change is right.
  • Review by a second AI model — The site's code is written with AI coding tools, chiefly Anthropic's Claude. Before a change is released it is reviewed by a different AI model, by default OpenAI's Codex, and the reviewing model is rotated between rounds so that no model signs off on its own work. A person decides when a review is finished.
  • One copy of each figure — At the end of every town and village data load, an automated check ends the load with an error if any government's year holds two added-up copies of the same filing from two different kinds of file (the Comptroller's summary workbook beside its account-level file), the fault that doubled the Village of Scarsdale's 2024 spending to $153.5 million. The check runs inside the load, so a failure undoes the whole load. It does not compare two files of the same kind. A second breakdown wrongly added inside a single file is a different error; the totals check above catches it where the source publishes a total, and the town and village account-level files publish none.

Corrections

When we find an error in a published figure, we fix it and list it here.

November 21, 2026 — Tax calculator: earned income credits counted a child of any age

From August 27, 2026, when the tax calculator began asking each child's age, until November 21, 2026, it counted every child toward the earned income credit whatever age was entered. The federal credit counts a child under 19 at the end of the year, with exceptions for some full-time students under 24 and for a permanently and totally disabled child (the IRS's qualifying-child rules), so a household that entered a child aged 19 or older could be shown a larger earned income credit than the age test gives, and larger state, county or city credits built on it. The amount did not always change: it stayed the same where the household's other children already reached the credit's largest band, or at incomes where the credit is not paid. This touched the calculator and its income chart for places whose state, county or city has a credit built on the federal one. In the calculator's estimate for a single filer earning $30,000 with one child aged 20, Washington, D.C. showed a refund of $2,565.33 where the tax is $620.18, and Rockville, Maryland a refund of $734.88 where the tax is $1,557.38. Credits that do not depend on the earned income credit, and exemptions for dependents, were not affected. We found the error on November 21, 2026, in a check of the calculator.

November 14, 2026 — Florida cities and counties: enterprise funds' interest and grants were left out of revenue

From April 3, 2026, when Florida's local finances first reached our site, until November 14, 2026, our Florida revenue figures left out the interest and grants that a government's enterprise and internal service funds receive (an enterprise fund runs a service such as a utility). The Department files these four accounts under its heading "Other Sources", and our readers left that heading out whole, because in the New York reports we hold it is the heading for transfers between a government's own funds. On 18 of our 476 Florida pages (14 cities, 3 towns and 1 county) the "Top Revenue Sources" list left out a category that belongs among its five, and on 2 of those (Umatilla and Wewahitchka) it is the largest. Arcadia's page left out $8,530,692 of these interest and grants for fiscal year 2025, its second-largest source; Pensacola's and Broward County's left out $57,143,034 and $84,251,167 for that year. The pages print no revenue total, and no other figure on them changes.

Our MCP server, which reads the same rows, gave Florida totals that were too low for as long as it has served Florida: its total revenue, and revenue per resident, for 1,333 of the 6,015 Florida governments and years we hold (821 for cities, 186 for towns, 34 for villages and 292 for counties), by $6.46 billion over fiscal years 2013 to 2025. 180 of those left out a twentieth or more of the government's revenue, and 31 a quarter or more; the most was the Town of White Springs, fiscal year 2021, with 65.5% left out. Arcadia's revenue per resident for fiscal year 2023 was given as $2,468, where it is $3,225.

We had known since October 30, 2026 that these accounts were left out, and from November 1, 2026 our MCP server's Florida revenue answers carried a note saying so. We fixed it by filing the four accounts under the Department's own heading for them, which our readers count. The two accounts left under "Other Sources", transfers to a county's commission from its tax collector and its supervisor of elections, stay left out, and a check now fails if any other Florida account we store is filed there.

November 14, 2026 — New York compliance page and place pages: annual-report filing and Fiscal Stress Monitoring scores were overstated

From February 22, 2026 until November 14, 2026, our New York compliance page said that counties, towns, villages and school districts had all filed every report, and from March 2, 2026 its overview table printed 100% in the annual-report column for each of them. The figure was typed into the page, not counted. For fiscal year 2025, the Comptroller holds reports from 56 of 57 counties, 833 of 933 towns, 468 of 531 villages and 689 of 689 school districts, so the page overstated filing for counties, towns and villages. From February 20, 2026, its city counts included New York City, which files no report with the Comptroller, as a filer: for fiscal year 2025 the page said 52 of 62 cities had filed, where 51 of 61 had; the percentage it printed, 84%, rounds the same. We found the errors on November 14, 2026, while checking every page's wording against our data; the column now counts each kind's reports, cities without New York City, and the sentences are built from those counts.

The same page's Fiscal Stress Monitoring System column, from March 2, 2026, counted a government as scored when the Comptroller's workbook listed it at all, including the governments it lists as "Not Filed" because it could not score them, and it counted New York City as scored. For fiscal year 2025 it showed 925 of 933 towns, 527 of 532 villages and 62 of 62 cities scored, where the Comptroller scored 819 towns, 429 villages and 50 of 61 cities (New York City is not in the system). Its counties' figure, 57 of 62, counted New York City's five borough counties, which the system does not cover, as never scored: 56 of 57 counties were scored. Its headline, "703 have never been scored", counted Census-designated places, which the system does not score; the governments it lists add up to 29. The same error reached place pages from March 1, 2026: at the fiscal year 2025 scores, it left the note that a place is missing from the latest scores off the pages of 218 governments (106 towns, 98 villages, 11 cities, a county and two school districts). Every count now reads the Comptroller's scores alone.

November 13, 2026 — New York City: debt service through the General Debt Service Fund was read from the wrong row

From February 20, 2026, when our New York City import was released, until November 13, 2026, the figure we stored for New York City's debt service through its General Debt Service Fund came from the wrong row of the Comptroller's table, the Hudson Yards debt service row printed below it: $58,655,000, $70,546,000 and $84,332,000 for fiscal years 2016 to 2018 and $0 for every later year we held, where the Comptroller reports between $3,377,653,000 and $5,137,881,000 a year ($3,851,631,000 for 2026). Until October 30, 2026, our sums of New York City's spending and of its debt service included this row (the same fault, fixed that day, counted many New York City figures twice), so those dollar sums were too high by the three amounts above for fiscal years 2016 to 2018 and unchanged for later years, and the figures built on them, per-resident spending and the debt service share of spending, moved with them. Since then no page has shown it and no total or chart has counted it; our MCP server returned it, ranked and per resident too, when the figure was asked for by name. We found the error on November 13, 2026, when we began comparing our New York City figures with the Comptroller's second printing of them (see Cross-Checking Against Source Totals); each year now reads the General Debt Service Fund's own row, and 2016's, which the report we import no longer prints, comes from the Comptroller's 2025 report.

November 12, 2026 — Three New York villages that changed their fiscal year: one year mixed two reports

From March 8 or 9, 2026, when town and village account-level figures first reached our site, until November 12, 2026, the pages for three New York villages showed revenue and spending for one year that mixed two of the village's reports. Each village moved its year end to December 31 and filed, under the same year, its 12-month report and a separate report for the seven months that followed. Our import kept one figure per account for the year, whichever came later in the Comptroller's file, so the year's totals matched neither report and changed when the Comptroller's file listed its rows in another order. The Village of Kiryas Joel's page showed fiscal year 2021 revenue of $17,861,308 ($19,888,003 from the Comptroller's March 2026 file) and spending of $33,174,826, where its 12-month report has $20,708,112 and $28,588,738. The Village of Schoharie's showed $1,491,392 and $1,310,446 for fiscal year 2020, where its 12-month report has $1,415,365 and $1,810,532; the Village of Middleburgh's showed $1,288,203 and $1,658,252 for fiscal year 2021, where its report has $1,248,733 and $1,436,584. The per-resident figures for those years were off by the same shares. Until November 6, 2026 these figures were also counted twice (see that correction). Our MCP server, which reads the same rows, gave the same figures. No other year or government is affected: in the Comptroller's files we hold, fiscal years 1995 to 2025, no other town, village, city, county, school district or fire district files two reports under one year.

We found the error on November 5, 2026, while comparing our totals with the Comptroller's own. Each year now shows the village's 12-month report, and each page's Data Notes give the seven-month report's dates and totals, which are in no year shown. The Comptroller's summary file shows the seven-month report for that year instead, so for these three years our figures and the summary's differ. An import now stops if a government files two reports under one year and it cannot tell which one is the 12-month report.

November 11, 2026 — Florida cities and counties: other general taxes were left out of fiscal years 2013 to 2020

From April 3, 2026, when Florida's local finances first reached our site, until November 11, 2026, the general government taxes charted on 100 of our 476 Florida pages (57 cities, 18 towns, 1 village and 24 counties) left out one of the Department's accounts, other general taxes, in fiscal years 2013 through 2020. 409 yearly figures on those charts were too low or missing: 402 rise with the fix, and 7, on 3 pages, appear where the chart had no figure for the year. Miami Beach's page showed $219,540,282 of general government taxes for fiscal year 2019, where the figure is $393,019,127; Okeechobee County's showed $24,565,274 for that year, where it is $32,510,830. On 14 pages a year's figure rises by more than a tenth, and on 5 of those by more than a quarter. No figure for fiscal years 2021 through 2025 changes, so the latest-year figure printed above each chart and the spending per resident at the top of each page stay as they were, and no page gains or loses a charted category.

Across the state the figures left out came to between $167.6 million (fiscal year 2013) and $286.1 million (fiscal year 2019) a year, and to $1.83 billion over the eight years: $1.65 billion for cities, towns and villages and $182 million for counties. Our MCP server, which reads the same rows, gave the same figures.

Until fiscal year 2020 the Department's file reports other general taxes under one account, numbered 319; from fiscal year 2021 it reports them under four (319.100, 319.200, 319.300 and 319.900). Our list of the Department's accounts was built from its 2025 list, which has only the four, and our import passed over a figure filed under an account that was not on our list, without reporting it. We found the error on November 10, 2026, by comparing each government's revenue with the Department's own total for it: the comparison named 409 governments and years, all in fiscal years 2013 through 2020, whose revenue fell short by this account's figure. We fixed it by adding the account as a line of its own, in the same category as the four that replaced it, and reading the Department's files for fiscal years 2013 through 2020 again. Of the 3,783 governments and years in those files that we hold, the revenue now differs from the Department's total by a dollar or more for one (Dade City, fiscal year 2020, by $748). An import now stops if a figure of a government it reads is filed under an account that is not on our list.

November 10, 2026 — Florida cities and counties: figures counted custodial and trust funds

From April 3, 2026, when Florida's local finances first reached our site, until November 10, 2026, our Florida figures added up every fund in the Department's file, including four kinds that hold money for others: custodial funds, pension trust funds, investment trust funds and private-purpose trust funds. A custodial fund holds money a government collects and passes on: a county's tax collector collects property taxes for the school district and the cities, and that money was counted as the county's own revenue and again as its spending when it was paid over. A pension trust fund holds employees' retirement money: its contributions and investment results were counted as the government's revenue, and its benefit payments as spending. 340 of our 476 Florida pages change with the fix (215 cities, 48 towns, 11 villages and all 66 counties we hold): 7,345 yearly figures on their charts, in fiscal years 2013 through 2025, the latest-year figure printed above 714 of those charts, and the spending per resident at the top of 265 pages, which falls on every one of them, by more than a tenth on 111 and by more than half on 22. Alachua County's page showed $4,960 of spending per resident for fiscal year 2025, where the figure is $2,049; Jacksonville's showed $10,118 for fiscal year 2024, where it is $5,676. Miami-Dade County's page showed $11,614,767,000 of general government taxes for fiscal year 2023, where the figure is $4,144,557,000. On 10 pages a different set of categories is now charted, and the ranking of Florida cities by spending per resident on our Florida page changed. 442 of the 7,345 changed yearly figures were too low, not too high: 239 are in fiscal year 2020, where impact fees were missing from our copy (below), and 189 in fiscal year 2022, when a fund left out could hold a loss, as many pension funds did: Pembroke Pines's page showed miscellaneous revenues of −$8,989,736 for that year, where the figure is $49,221,466.

Across the state, counties' revenue for fiscal year 2024 falls from $111.8 billion to $59.7 billion and their spending from $103.1 billion to $53.6 billion; the revenue of cities, towns and villages falls from $58.6 billion to $42.5 billion and their spending from $45.8 billion to $37.9 billion. For counties nearly all of it begins in fiscal year 2021, the first year the Department's file reports custodial funds: for fiscal years 2013 through 2019 the fix moves counties' revenue and spending by less than half of one percent. Our MCP server, which reads the same rows, gave the same figures, and its balance-sheet lines counted the same funds: for cities, towns and villages in fiscal year 2024 they fall from $147.0 billion to $91.3 billion.

The Department's file reports every account by fund group, twelve in all, and our import added all twelve. The Department's own Total Revenue and Total Expenditures, in its report for fiscal year 2024, leave these four out. We found the error on November 10, 2026, while preparing to compare our Florida totals with the Department's, and fixed it by counting only the eight fund groups a government runs for itself, in every year we hold, for revenue, spending and balance-sheet figures, and by removing the figures that existed only in the four left out. To do it we read the Department's files for fiscal years 2013 through 2020 again. That added the impact fees our copy of fiscal year 2020 lacked ($1,184,816,131 for 244 governments, where we had held $3,536,605 for 3), and it showed that the impact fees of fiscal years 2013 through 2019 had been counted once, as we believed.

November 10, 2026 — Florida cities and counties: impact fees were counted twice

From November 4, 2026 until November 10, 2026, the "Permits, Fees, And Special Assessments" figure on 263 Florida pages (180 cities, 38 towns, 8 villages and 37 counties) counted every impact fee twice, in fiscal years 2021 through 2025. An impact fee is a one-time charge on new construction that pays for the roads, parks, schools and utilities the growth needs. The chart of that category showed 1,139 yearly figures that were wrong, and on 235 of the pages the latest-year figure printed above the chart was one of them. On 168 pages more than a tenth of at least one year's figure was the second copy, and on 93 more than a quarter. Palm Coast's page showed $118,929,731 for fiscal year 2025, where the figure is $60,323,360; Osceola County's showed $398,892,281 for fiscal year 2021, where it is $246,476,511. All but one of the 1,139 were too high: Stuart reported a negative impact fee for fiscal year 2023, so its page showed $2,653,514 where the figure is $3,733,042. No page gains or loses a charted category. Across Florida's cities and counties the second copy came to between $1.65 billion and $1.91 billion a year. Our MCP server, which reads the same rows, answered with the same doubled fees, in its category figures and in its revenue totals for these governments.

The Department's file prints each impact fee in two of its sections, under one identifier, and our import added up every printing. Spending and the other revenue categories were not affected. The Department's own Total Revenue for each government, which it publishes in a separate report, is not added up the way our figures are: it leaves out the custodial and trust funds, and it counts receipts we leave out of revenue, such as money a government moves between its own funds and money it borrows. The lines in the Department's file, added up the Department's way, equal that total to the dollar with each fee counted once for 118 of the 232 governments with an impact fee that are in both reports for fiscal year 2024, and with each fee counted twice for none of them. The City of Lake Alfred's audited financial statements for fiscal year 2024 report $5,588,976 of impact fees in its Impact Fee Fund, which equals one copy to the dollar. Fiscal years 2013 through 2019 were loaded from an earlier form of the file; their impact fees ($1.23 billion statewide in fiscal year 2019) run level with the corrected later years ($1.73 billion in fiscal year 2021), so we believe they were counted once. We found the error on November 10, 2026, while preparing to compare our Florida totals with the Department's, and fixed it by counting a figure once however many times the file prints it.

November 8, 2026 — North Carolina: two unincorporated communities showed a same-named town's or village's finances

From April 5, 2026, when we first showed North Carolina's local finances, until November 8, 2026, the page for Fairview, an unincorporated community in Buncombe County, showed the Annual Financial Information Report figures of the Town of Fairview in Union County, fiscal years 2012 through 2025, and the page for Flat Rock, an unincorporated community in Surry County, showed those of the Village of Flat Rock in Henderson County, fiscal years 2012 through 2025. Each page's per-resident spending divided one place's spending by another place's residents: Fairview's page showed $325 for fiscal year 2025, where the town's own figure is $206; Flat Rock's page showed $2,714 for fiscal year 2024, where the village's own figure is $816. The town's and the village's own pages showed no finances at all, and our MCP server, which reads the same rows, answered the same way.

Our import matched each filer's name to our list of places by its bare name across every kind of place, and a Census-designated place with the same name was found before the town or village, which we store as "Town of Fairview (Union County)". The figures themselves were right; only the page they sat on was wrong, for two of the 550 filers. The two communities' own figures, their Census population, were right. We found the error on November 7, 2026, in a review of this page's wording against the code, and fixed it by matching filers only to cities, towns and villages, and by moving the two filers' figures to their own pages. A third community, Centerville in Franklin County, holds the figures of the former Town of Centerville for fiscal years 2012 through 2016; the town dissolved its charter on June 22, 2017 (Session Law 2017-43), and the Census Bureau now lists the area as a Census-designated place, so those figures are the place's own and stay.

November 8, 2026 — New York cities and counties: category charts and debt service counted the trust and custodial fund

From January 27, 2026, when we first showed them, until November 8, 2026, the figures for a category's revenue or spending in a year, which the charts on a place's page and our MCP server's category answers are built from, counted the trust and custodial fund for 104 New York cities and counties (51 cities, 53 counties): money a government holds or collects for others, which we leave out of every total. The totals and per-resident figures on the same pages were right; the category figures were not. A page charts its five largest categories, chosen without the fund, so not every inflated figure reached a chart: today 99 of the 104 pages (48 cities, 51 counties) chart at least one. The pages' Debt Service line and "Debt Service %" figure, and the county comparison charts' debt service, read the same way (Saratoga County, 2002 through 2013, by at most $6,303 of $1,483,153). Our MCP server's category and debt-service answers counted the fund from February 19, 2026. The "aid dependent" share that colors the dots on the stress analysis chart and fills a column of each place's stress trajectory page divided aid by revenue that counted the fund, so it read too low: in fiscal year 2024, 59 of 115 city and county shares change, Glen Cove's from 10.0% to 22.8% and New Rochelle's from 7.9% to 18.1%. Fiscal years 1995 through 2025 are affected. In fiscal year 2024 the error touched 171 category figures, 90 of them on a chart, and 88 by more than a tenth, 54 of those on a chart: New Rochelle's "Other Local Revenues" chart showed $289,050,253 where the city's own revenue is $15,364,018; Glen Cove's showed $93,612,865 where it is $3,916,427, 24 times too high, and Glen Cove's "General Government" spending $99,038,103 where it is $9,341,665.

Totals, rankings and per-capita figures were right, as were towns, villages, school districts and every other state, whose data holds no such fund. Which five categories a page charts was chosen without the fund, so no chart gains or loses a category. We found the error on November 7, 2026, in a review of this page's wording against the code, and fixed it by giving every sum one shared rule for which rows add up.

November 7, 2026 — New York towns that share a village with another town: Part-Town Per Capita Spending

From March 9, 2026, when we first showed it, until November 7, 2026, the pages for 50 New York towns that share a village with another town showed a "Part-Town Per Capita Spending" figure and its chart, next to a note saying the figure was not yet available. The figure divides the spending that serves only the area outside villages by the town's residents outside villages. For these towns we do not know how many of the shared village's residents live in each town, so the figure was meant to be withheld: our code held a list of the 53 towns by short name, but every town's name also carries its county, so the list matched none of them. In the town the Comptroller files the shared village under, the whole village was subtracted from the residents, so the figure was too high; in the other towns none of it was, so the figure was too low. The error can be as large as the shared village's population. The Town of Mamaroneck showed $4,872 for 2025, dividing by 4,843 residents after the whole Village of Mamaroneck was subtracted, part of which lies in the Town of Rye; the Town of Clay showed $232 and the Town of Cicero $423, each with the Village of North Syracuse counted wholly in Clay.

The Town-Wide figure, which divides by all of a town's residents, was right, as were every other town's figures, the villages' own pages and the comparability notes. We found the error on November 7, 2026, while checking this page's new wording against the code.

November 6, 2026 — New York towns and villages: per-resident answers from our MCP server

From February 2026, when we first loaded town and village data, until November 6, 2026, our MCP server, which AI assistants use to read this data, could divide a New York town's or village's spending or revenue by either of two population figures for the same year: the Census Bureau's estimate, or the Comptroller's figure, which repeats the 2010 or 2020 census count. Which one it used depended on the order the database returned them. The two figures are a median of 1.6% apart for towns and 4.7% for villages, and more than 20% apart in about 7% of years, so an answer could be off by that much: for the Village of Scarsdale in 2024 it answered $4,947 per resident instead of $5,014.

Our pages used the Census figure and were not affected, nor were cities, counties, school districts or other states, which have only the Census figure. One chart year on our pages changes with the new rule: Village of Edwards, 2013, from $684 to $834 per resident. We found the error on November 5, 2026, in a review of our code.

November 6, 2026 — Utah income tax rate

From April 19, 2026, when we published it, until November 6, 2026, the Tax Snapshot table on our Utah state page and on the pages for places in Utah said "Utah imposes a flat individual income tax rate of 4.5% under current statute." Utah had already lowered the rate to 4.45% for tax years starting on or after January 1, 2026 (S.B. 60 of the 2026 General Session, signed March 23, 2026 and in effect from May 6, 2026), so the stated rate was 0.05 percentage points too high for 2026: $5 on every $10,000 of taxable income.

The tax calculator does not yet compute Utah's income tax, so no calculated figure used the old rate. We found the error on November 6, 2026, while reading Utah's current code for our retirement-income research.

November 6, 2026 — New York towns and villages

From March 8 or 9, 2026 until November 6, 2026, town and village pages added together two copies of the same Comptroller data for fiscal years 1997 to 2024, so their revenue and spending figures were too high. Statewide in fiscal year 2023, spending read about 55% too high for towns and 59% for villages, and revenue about 65% and 67%. Property tax figures read about 1.65 times the correct amount for towns and nearly double for villages. Fiscal year 2025 held only four funds and read too low.

The per-resident trend cards were also wrong for 2011 to 2015 and from 2020 on, because they divided by two population figures added together. A town's cards showed about half the correct amount (Town of Bethlehem, 2020: $368 shown, $736 correct). On a village's card the dollars and the residents were both too high, which partly cancelled (Village of Scarsdale, 2024: $4,233 shown, $5,014 correct).

About 1,490 pages were affected. Our MCP server, which AI assistants use to read this data, gave the same too-high revenue and spending answers for towns and villages. Cities, counties, school districts, other states and the tax calculator were not affected. We found the error on November 5, 2026, by comparing our totals with the Comptroller's own.

Town and village totals are now added from one copy, across every fund except Trust & Custodial. When we made the fix we compared them with the Comptroller's summary totals for every town and village year where we hold both, 81,685 comparisons of revenue and spending. One summary column was left out: a 2011 "Local Revenues" subtotal that the summary lists beside the lines it adds up. 93% matched to the dollar. About 5% were within $10, most of them in 2000 to 2008, when the summary is in whole dollars. About 2%, almost all in 2010 to 2019, matched to within $10 once trust funds were added, which the summary then counted and our totals leave out. The remaining 97 (about 0.1%) are not yet explained.

Data Accuracy

All financial data on this site comes from official government filings: the NYS Office of the State Comptroller for 61 cities, 57 counties, 933 towns, 561 villages (including dissolved villages' history) and 689 school districts; the NYC Comptroller's ACFR for New York City; the California State Controller for 483 cities and 57 counties; the Florida Department of Financial Services for 410 cities, towns and villages and 66 counties; the North Carolina Department of State Treasurer for its cities, towns, villages and 100 counties; and New York's Fiscal Stress Monitoring System, run by the State Comptroller, for stress scores. A few figures for places in Maryland, Virginia, the District of Columbia, Massachusetts and Ohio come from those governments' own published reports. Demographic data comes from the US Census Bureau's American Community Survey. County council partisan composition is sourced from county board of elections results (November 2025). While we take care to import, validate, and present this data accurately, we cannot guarantee completeness or freedom from errors. If you spot a discrepancy, please contact us at [email protected].

The tax calculator and the retirement-income page show the source of each figure beside it. The calculator's income chart joins exact results at the incomes its slider stops on and is drawn straight between them. Where a child's age is entered, the calculator counts the child toward an earned income credit only through age 18 and asks nothing else about the child. The IRS's qualifying-child rules also count a full-time student under 24 (enrolled for at least five months of the year) and a child permanently and totally disabled at any time during the year, so for a household with such a child the calculator may show a smaller credit than the household would get. The rules also require the child to be younger than the filer, which the calculator does not check. Our MCP server, which AI assistants use to read this data, is described at benchmarkusa.org/blog/mcp/.